Skip to content

Back to Blog / Calling

Voicemail Scripts That Get Callbacks: Five Templates for Insurance Agents

The five parts of a voicemail people return, five scripts for health, life, P&C renewals and referrals, how many to leave, and why recorded drops and ringless voicemail need consent.

Voicemail Scripts That Get Callbacks: Five Templates for Insurance Agents
Calling

The short answer

A voicemail that gets a call back is short, specific and easy to act on: your name and agency first, the reason the person knows you, one concrete reason to call, and your number said twice, slowly. Aim for about 20 to 30 seconds. Leave one on your first attempt and one more later in the sequence, send a text right after each, and stop leaving them once a lead has heard from you twice.

What the data says (and doesn't)

A magnifying glass over a paper bar chart with one tall blue bar beside a cassette tape

There is no independent, peer-reviewed study of insurance voicemail callbacks. What exists is vendor research, so treat it as directional:

  • Gong analyzed B2B cold calls and found that leaving a voicemail roughly doubled reply rates to the emails that followed, while three or more voicemails pushed replies down. Gong suggests about 15 seconds for a first voicemail and about 30 for a second (Gong).
  • Velocify found leads who received two voicemails across six call attempts were 34% more likely to convert than leads who received none, and that five or six voicemails did worse than none (Velocify).

The pattern is consistent: a couple of good voicemails help, and a pile of them hurts.

The five parts of a voicemail that works

A vintage microphone beside five blue paper dots in a row
  1. Who you are, in the first five seconds. Name, agency and, if they will recognize it, the carrier or line of business.
  2. Why they know you. "You asked for a quote on…" or "Your policy renews on…". This is what separates you from spam.
  3. One reason to call back. A specific answer, a deadline or a saving, not "touching base".
  4. Your number, twice, slowly. Say it once in the middle and once at the end.
  5. A text right after. Many people read a text before they play a voicemail. Send a one-line text that matches the message.

Scripts you can adapt

A hand writing on a notepad beside a desk phone handset and a coffee cup

First attempt on a new internet lead

"Hi Dana, this is [your name] with [your agency]. You asked for a health insurance quote online this morning. I have two plans that fit what you entered, and one starts at a lower premium than you might expect. Call or text me back at [number]. That's [number]. Talk soon."

Second attempt, with a deadline

"Hi Dana, [your name] with [your agency] again, following up on your health insurance quote. To start coverage on January 1, we need to finish your application by December 15. It takes about fifteen minutes on the phone. Call me at [number], that's [number]."

Renewal review, any line

"Hi Mr. Lee, it's [your name] at [your agency]. Your auto policy renews on March 3, and the new rate is out. I'd like ten minutes to check your discounts before then. Call me at [number], again [number]."

Life or final expense follow-up

"Hi Ruth, this is [your name] with [your agency]. You asked about coverage to help your family with final expenses. I have the numbers you wanted and a few options in your budget. Call me back at [number]. That's [number]."

Referral introduction

"Hi Jordan, this is [your name] with [your agency]. [Referrer's name] said you were looking at home insurance and asked me to reach out. I'd be glad to compare your current policy, no pressure. My number is [number], [number]."

Fill in the brackets with your own details, and keep each script to what you would actually say out loud.

Mistakes that kill callbacks

Scissors cutting a tangled cassette tape ribbon
  • Long introductions. If your reason comes after twenty seconds, it never gets heard.
  • Vague asks. "Give me a call when you get a chance" gives nobody a reason to.
  • Reading a script word for word. Write it down, then say it like a person.
  • Fast numbers. Say the number at dictation speed. People write it down while you talk.
  • Too many voicemails. After two, switch to texts and email and a final "closing the file" message.
A hand signing a form with a fountain pen next to a smartphone

A voicemail you leave live, in your own voice, during a call is part of that call. A prerecorded voicemail drop or a ringless voicemail is different: the FCC ruled in 2022 that ringless voicemail to a cell phone is a call using a prerecorded voice, which needs the consumer's prior consent (FCC 22-85). Prerecorded messages must also identify the business at the start and give a phone number (47 CFR 64.1200), and the FCC treats AI-generated voices as artificial voices. If you use drops at all, check your consent language with a compliance professional first.

Where ApexSales.ai fits

A smartphone with a chat bubble linked by a dotted line to a desk phone handset

In ApexSales.ai you can log each voicemail as a call outcome and have an automation send the matching text a minute later. A follow-up sequence then sets the next attempt, stops when the lead replies, and checks DNC status and quiet hours before each touch.

General information, not legal advice.

New to a term in this article? See the sales and compliance glossary.

  • Voicemail
  • Scripts
  • Callbacks
  • Follow-Up
  • Calling
Aisel VerdievaContent, ApexSales.ai

Helping insurance agents grow their business through automation, compliance, and proven strategies.

FAQ

Frequently Asked Questions

ApexSales.aiQuestions agents ask us
Today

About 20 to 30 seconds. Vendor data from Gong suggests around 15 seconds for a first voicemail and around 30 for a second. Long messages tend to get deleted before the reason is heard.

ApexSales.ai

Two is a sensible limit. Velocify found two voicemails across six attempts beat leaving none, while five or six did worse than none. After two, switch to texts and email.

ApexSales.ai

Yes, if the lead agreed to receive texts. Many people read texts before they listen to voicemails, and a short matching text makes your callback number easy to tap.

ApexSales.ai

The FCC ruled in 2022 that ringless voicemail to a wireless number is a call made with a prerecorded voice, so it requires the consumer's prior consent. Check your consent language with a compliance professional before using drops.

ApexSales.ai
Still have a question? Message us

Ready to transform your insurance sales?

See how ApexSales.ai automates follow-ups, runs DNC and quiet-hours checks, and books appointments for insurance agents.